3D printer filament types compared: PLA, PETG, ABS, ASA, TPU and nylon

· 6 min read

A filament spool standing on its edge, drawn grey with black edges, with its filament wound in yellow and a loose end curling off the top

Most 3D prints are PLA, and for models and prototypes it’s the right choice. The other five are for parts PLA can’t handle, and each one fixes a different weakness. To compare them fairly, every number below comes from one maker’s data sheets, where all six were printed and tested the same way.

What's on the list

The six filament types a home printer can print, from PLA to nylon. Each card has the spool rendered in CadFlow, a photo of a real part made from it, a part made in CadFlow in that filament, its numbers drawn against the other five, the print settings, the price, two pros and two cons.

Where the numbers come from

Polymaker's technical data sheets for six of its filaments, read on 29 October 2026. We checked them against Prusament's sheets: strength agrees within a few MPa, and heat does too except for ASA, which Prusament puts at 93 °C.

Prices

Polymaker's own US store on 29 October 2026, for most colours, before tax. TPU and nylon only come in 0.75 kg spools.

If you’re printing Use
Models, prototypes and your first prints PLA
Brackets, clips and parts that get handled PETG
Parts that get warm or get knocked about ABS, with an enclosure
Anything that lives outside ASA, with an enclosure
Parts that bend: cases, feet, seals TPU
Gears, hinges and parts under real load Nylon
PLA: a spool of PLA filament, rendered in CadFlowPLA filament
PLA: 3D printed PLA gears, a fan impeller and a gearbox laid out on a white backgroundPrinted gears
PLA: a phone stand to be printed in PLA, made in CadFlowA phone stand, made in CadFlow

PLA in numbers

Softens at60 °C

Strength, flat and upright52.3 and 40.5 MPa

Toughness, notched impact3.3 kJ/m²

Water it takes up0.51 %

The grey marks are the other five filaments.

PLA

Polylactic acid

$19.99 for 1 kg

Nozzle
190 to 230 °C
Bed
25 to 60 °C
Enclosure
Not needed
Softens at
60 °C
Strength, printed flat
52.3 MPa
Drying
Only if it's damp: 55 °C for 6 h

The one most people start with and keep using. It prints on any printer, cold bed or warm, with little warping, and it's the stiffest of the six, so it's right for models, prototypes and anything that stays indoors.

  • Prints on any printer, with no enclosure and little warping
  • The stiffest of the six, and stronger than PETG when printed flat
  • Softens at 60 °C, the lowest of the six apart from TPU
  • Brittle: it cracks rather than bends, and takes a knock worst of the six

Data: Polymaker PolyLite PLA · Picture: made in CadFlow

PETG: a spool of PETG filament, rendered in CadFlowPETG filament
PETG: an open black carry case 3D printed in PETG, with red TPU compartments holding four handheld metersA printed carry case
PETG: a cable clip to be printed in PETG, made in CadFlowA cable clip, made in CadFlow

PETG in numbers

Softens at69 °C

Strength, flat and upright47.96 and 45.71 MPa

Toughness, notched impact4.95 kJ/m²

Water it takes up0.51 %

The grey marks are the other five filaments.

PETG

Polyethylene terephthalate glycol

$19.99 for 1 kg

Nozzle
240 to 260 °C
Bed
60 to 70 °C
Enclosure
Not needed
Softens at
69 °C
Strength, printed flat
47.96 MPa
Drying
60 °C for 6 h

The step up from PLA for parts that get used: brackets, clips, holders and anything that takes a little heat or water. It costs the same as PLA, needs no enclosure, and its layers hold together better than any of the others.

  • Almost as strong between layers as along them, the best of the six
  • No enclosure needed and little smell, at the same price as PLA
  • Takes up water from the air, and damp PETG strings
  • Softens at 69 °C, only a little above PLA

Data: Polymaker PETG · Picture: made in CadFlow

ABS: a spool of ABS filament, rendered in CadFlowABS filament
ABS: rows of black jig parts 3D printed in ABS, on the print bedPrinted jigs
ABS: a headphone hook to be printed in ABS, made in CadFlowA headphone hook, made in CadFlow

ABS in numbers

Softens at100 °C

Strength, flat and upright33.4 and 29.7 MPa

Toughness, notched impact18 kJ/m²

Water it takes up0.35 %

The grey marks are the other five filaments.

ABS

Acrylonitrile butadiene styrene

$19.99 for 1 kg

Nozzle
245 to 265 °C
Bed
90 to 100 °C
Enclosure
Needed
Softens at
100 °C
Strength, printed flat
33.4 MPa
Drying
70 °C for 6 h

The plastic LEGO bricks are made of, for parts that get warm or get knocked about. It needs an enclosure: Polymaker says an open printer is fine only for parts up to about the size of a fist.

  • Softens at 100 °C, 40 degrees above PLA
  • Tough: it takes a notched knock five times better than PLA
  • Needs an enclosure, or bigger parts warp
  • Smells while printing, so Polymaker advises good ventilation

Data: Polymaker PolyLite ABS · Picture: made in CadFlow

ASA: a spool of ASA filament, rendered in CadFlowASA filament
ASA: a dark green Husqvarna Automower robot mower on a lawn, its body moulded in ASA (BASF Luran S)A robot mower body, moulded in ASA
ASA: a garden hose hook to be printed in ASA, made in CadFlowA garden hose hook, made in CadFlow

ASA in numbers

Softens at103 °C

Strength, flat and upright43.8 and 32 MPa

Toughness, notched impact10.3 kJ/m²

Water it takes up0.4 %

The grey marks are the other five filaments.

ASA

Acrylonitrile styrene acrylate

$26.99 for 1 kg

Nozzle
230 to 260 °C
Bed
75 to 95 °C
Enclosure
Needed
Softens at
103 °C
Strength, printed flat
43.8 MPa
Drying
70 °C for 7 h

ABS made to stay outside. It prints the same way, needs the same enclosure and takes the same heat, but it doesn't fade or go brittle in the sun, so it's the one for garden parts and anything that lives on a balcony.

  • Made for the sun: Polymaker measured almost no colour change after two years outdoors
  • Softens at 103 °C, and it's stronger than ABS
  • Needs an enclosure and ventilation, like ABS
  • Costs about a third more than PLA, PETG or ABS

Data: Polymaker ASA · Picture: made in CadFlow

TPU: a spool of TPU filament, rendered in CadFlowTPU filament
TPU: two hands twisting a flexible yellow lattice strip 3D printed in TPUIt bends and twists
TPU: a keychain tag to be printed in TPU, made in CadFlowA keychain tag, made in CadFlow

TPU in numbers

Stretches before it breaks551.2 %

Water it takes up0.82 %

HardnessShore 95A, like a firm rubber

The grey marks are the other five filaments.

TPU

Thermoplastic polyurethane, shore 95A

$29.99 for 0.75 kg

Nozzle
210 to 230 °C
Bed
25 to 60 °C
Enclosure
Not needed
Softens at
Not given, it's soft
Strength, printed flat
Stretches 6.5 times its length
Drying
70 °C for 8 h

Rubbery filament for parts that bend and spring back: phone cases, feet, seals, bumpers and grips. This one is 95A, firm for a TPU, and it prints at PLA temperatures with no enclosure.

  • Stretches to more than six times its length before it breaks
  • Prints at PLA temperatures, on a cold bed, with no enclosure
  • Needs a direct drive extruder; Polymaker advises against Bowden printers
  • Takes up more water than anything here but nylon, so dry it first

Data: Polymaker PolyFlex TPU95 · Picture: made in CadFlow

Nylon: a spool of Nylon filament, rendered in CadFlowNylon filament
Nylon: a black snow machine nozzle 3D printed in nylon, resting on a spool of black filamentA printed nozzle
Nylon: a bearing block to be printed in Nylon, made in CadFlowA bearing block, made in CadFlow

Nylon in numbers

Softens at (annealed)111 °C

Strength, flat and upright78 and 45.8 MPa

Toughness, notched impact6.9 kJ/m²

Water it takes up2.82 %

The grey marks are the other five filaments.

Nylon

Polyamide (PA), here a nylon 6 and 6/66 copolymer

$49.99 for 0.75 kg

Nozzle
250 to 270 °C
Bed
25 to 50 °C
Enclosure
Needed
Softens at
111 °C
Strength, printed flat
78 MPa
Drying
100 °C for 8 h, then print from a dryer

The strongest of the six and the one that takes the most heat, for gears, hinges and parts under real load. The catch is water: nylon soaks it up from the air, so it has to be dried and printed straight from a dryer, and a part that has taken up water is less than half as strong.

  • The strongest of the six: 78 MPa printed flat, half again as much as PLA
  • Softens at 111 °C once annealed, the most heat of the six
  • Takes up water fast, so it needs drying and printing straight from a dryer
  • The most expensive: $49.99 for a 0.75 kg spool

Data: Polymaker PolyMide CoPA · Picture: made in CadFlow

To see what one print costs in any of them, use our 3D print cost calculator.

Which ones take heat

The heat deflection temperature is where a test bar under a light load (0.45 MPa) starts to bend. It’s the number to look at when a part will get warm. PLA gives up at 60 °C and PETG at 69 °C, while ABS and ASA hold until about 100 °C.

Nylon111 °CPolymaker PolyMide CoPA, after annealing at 80 °C for 6 h
ASA103 °CPolymaker ASA
ABS100 °CPolymaker PolyLite ABS
PETG69 °CPolymaker PETG
PLA60 °CPolymaker PolyLite PLA
Heat deflection temperature at 0.45 MPa (ISO 75), from Polymaker's data sheets. Nylon's is after annealing at 80 °C for 6 hours. Polymaker gives none for TPU, which is soft at any temperature.
Show as a table
FilamentBends at
Nylon111 °C
ASA103 °C
ABS100 °C
PETG69 °C
PLA60 °C

Strength depends on which way you print

A print is weakest between its layers, because each layer only fuses to the one below it. Polymaker tests every material both ways, printed flat so the pull runs along the layers and printed upright so it pulls them apart. PLA loses about a quarter of its strength across the layers and nylon about 40 %, while PETG keeps 95 % of it.

So a hook printed standing up, with the load pulling its layers apart, can snap where the same hook printed lying down would hold. Turn a part so its load runs along the layers, and if it can’t, PETG is the filament that minds least.

Printed flat, pulled along the layersPrinted upright, pulled across them

Nylon, flat78 MPaPolymaker PolyMide CoPA
Nylon, upright45.8 MPa59 % of its flat strength
PLA, flat52.3 MPaPolymaker PolyLite PLA
PLA, upright40.5 MPa77 % of its flat strength
PETG, flat48 MPaPolymaker PETG
PETG, upright45.7 MPa95 % of its flat strength
ASA, flat43.8 MPaPolymaker ASA
ASA, upright32 MPa73 % of its flat strength
ABS, flat33.4 MPaPolymaker PolyLite ABS
ABS, upright29.7 MPa89 % of its flat strength
Tensile strength (ISO 527) of test bars printed at 100 % infill, from Polymaker's data sheets. Nylon was annealed and dried before testing. TPU stretches instead, to about six and a half times its length before it breaks.
Show as a table
FilamentTensile strength
Nylon, flat78 MPa
Nylon, upright45.8 MPa
PLA, flat52.3 MPa
PLA, upright40.5 MPa
PETG, flat48 MPa
PETG, upright45.7 MPa
ASA, flat43.8 MPa
ASA, upright32 MPa
ABS, flat33.4 MPa
ABS, upright29.7 MPa

Strength in a pull isn’t everything. ABS is the weakest of the five in this chart, but in the notched impact test it takes a knock five times better than PLA, and better than nylon too while the nylon is dry.

Water, and why nylon needs a dryer

Every filament takes up some water from the air, and damp filament prints worse: Polymaker says damp PETG strings, for example. Nylon takes up far more than the rest, which is why its sheet says to dry it at 100 °C for 8 hours and print it straight from a dryer. Keep any spool sealed in a bag with desiccant untill you print with it.

Nylon2.82 %100 °C for 8 h, then print from a dryer
TPU0.82 %70 °C for 8 h
PLA0.51 %Only if it's damp: 55 °C for 6 h
PETG0.51 %60 °C for 6 h
ASA0.40 %70 °C for 7 h
ABS0.35 %70 °C for 6 h
Water each filament takes up from the air when it's left out long enough, as a share of its weight, read from the moisture curves in Polymaker's data sheets.
Show as a table
FilamentWater taken up
Nylon2.82 %
TPU0.82 %
PLA0.51 %
PETG0.51 %
ASA0.40 %
ABS0.35 %

Water changes the part as well as the print. Polymaker soaked nylon test bars in 60 °C water for 48 hours: they held 34 MPa instead of 78, but took a notched knock four times better. A nylon part that lives in a damp place ends up weaker but tougher than its dry numbers.

Not on the list

Many brands sell blends called PLA+, silk PLA or matte PLA. They print like PLA, but what’s in them and how strong they are varies by brand, so check that brand’s sheet. Polycarbonate (PC) and the carbon or glass filled versions of PLA, PETG and nylon are for stiffer or hotter parts. The filled ones wear out brass nozzles, so they need a hardened steel nozzle.

Parts like these in CadFlow

We make CadFlow, a 3D program for things you build, which plays the build back as a step-by-step video that anyone can follow. It isn’t public yet. If you'd like to try it, join the waitlist.

Questions people ask

Which filament is the strongest?

Of these six, nylon: 78 MPa printed flat in Polymaker's tests, against 52 for PLA and 48 for PETG. Printed upright, nylon and PETG are almost level, at 45.8 and 45.7 MPa.

Is PLA food safe?

Polymaker doesn't say so: the shop pages for its PLA, PETG, ABS and ASA say "we do not have any data whether this material is food safe". Prusament says PLA itself is food safe, but advises against eating or drinking from prints again and again, because bacteria can build up in small cracks in a printed surface. A food-safe coating helps with that.

Do I need an enclosure?

Not for PLA, PETG or TPU. ABS and ASA need one to keep bigger parts from warping. Polymaker's nylon data sheet asks for one too, although its shop page says it isn't needed.

What's the difference between ABS and ASA?

They print almost the same way and take about the same heat, 100 and 103 °C. ASA is made to stand up to sunlight: Polymaker measured almost no colour change after two years outdoors. ABS is a little cheaper and takes a knock better, while ASA is stronger in a pull.

Why does my filament string?

Often because it's damp. Polymaker says wet PETG strings, and its data sheets give a drying temperature and time for each filament, from 55 °C for PLA to 100 °C for nylon.

Where do the numbers come from?

From Polymaker's data sheets for PolyLite PLA, Polymaker PETG, PolyLite ABS, Polymaker ASA, PolyFlex TPU95 and PolyMide CoPA, read on 29 October 2026, and its shop pages for prices and what it says each material is good at. We checked them against Prusament's sheets. Prusament measures stiffness a different way, so we don't compare stiffness here.

Free tools for this

History of this post

  1. Published
Every post by its last update

This blog is by the team making CadFlow, where you build your project in 3D and show how it goes together.

See how CadFlow works